It must be beginning to snow in many parts of the northern hemisphere. I am posting this little poem of the joys of winter. Just think of mulled wine! Any plonk will do! No blanc though! Even plonk noveau!
Bai Juyi (772-846): At Home to Mr. Liu Shijiu
1 (At home----an ebony, foamy new wine,)
At home: an ebony, bubbly new wine,
(revised 8.12.15)
2 (On a little red-clay fire stove warming.)
On a little stove of red clay, warming.
(revised 4.12.15)
3 Care for a cup of the good stuff? I say,
4 (Ah snow, in the evening sky, is forming.)
Ah, snow in the evening sky is forming.
(revised 4.12.15)
Translated by Andrew W.F. Wong (Huang Hongfa) 譯者: 黃宏發
20th July 2009 (revised 21.7.09; 2.8.09; 1.12.09)
Translated from the original - 白居易: 問劉十九
1 綠螘新醅酒
2 紅泥小火爐
3 晚來天欲雪
4 能飲一杯無
Notes:
* This English rendition is in tetrameter (4 metrical feet) while the original is in 5-character lines. The rhyme scheme is XAXA as in the original.
* Title and line 1: I take the “wine” to be at the poet’s home. The word問 in the title means “asking/inviting”, hence, “At Home” which is an invitation for drinks (and tit bits) at home. “At home” is also added to line 1 to indicate in the poem itself where the “wine” is.
* Line 1: The “new wine” 新醅酒 is a newly fermented, [deleted 8.12.15: unstrained] unfiltered rice wine, often dark in colour, with foams floating on top. The character 螘 is the ancient character, which is still used, for 蟻 meaning ants, and the foams on the “new wine” had been referred to in classical Chinese as 浮螘(蟻) floating ants or 浮蛆 floating maggots, neither very palatable if not disgusting. I have therefore decided to simply describe it as “foamy” [added 8.12.15: which is now amended to read "bubbly"]. The very first character of the poem 綠 which means green cannot be green as green ants, as far as I know, do not exist. [Added 8.12.15: Although I now know green ants do exist in Australia (like black swans?), they most certainly did not exist in China then.] It must mean black or dark as in 綠髮 (green hair) and 青絲 (green silk) both refer to “black hair” in Chinese poetry, hence, I have decided for “ ebony”. If one insists on translating 綠 literally as "green" in contrast to "red" 紅 in line 2, I had considered but rejected “greenish” which, together with “new wine”, produces a beautiful yet wrong image of a Portugese “vino verde” which in the West, is drunk chilled. [Added 8.12.15: Or, perhaps, the Korean unfiltered rice wine "makkoli" which is more cream coloured than greenish and which, again, is usually drunk cold or chilled in Korea (although I had tried to drink warmed and found it pleasant in a different way.]
* Line 2: I have added “warming” which is implicit in the original.
* Lines 3 and 4: I have reversed the order of the 2 lines for the rhyme. I had considered changing line 3 (line 4 of the original) from a question to an exhortation, viz. “Do come for a cup of the good stuff, I pray,” but have decided to be more faithful to the original, hence, "Care for a cup of the good stuff? I say". [Language polished 8.12.15]
I have polished it further by substituting "bubbly" for "foamy" in line 1 and changing the order of words in line 2, thus:
ReplyDelete1 At home -- an ebony, bubbly new wine,
2 On a little fire stove of red clay warming.
Andrew Wong.
I have further revised my rendition of this little poem which now reads:-
ReplyDelete1 At home: an ebony, bubbly new wine,
2 On a little stove of red clay warming.
3 Care for a cup of the good stuff? I say;
4 Ah, snow in the ev'ning sky is forming.
hi, andrew, as there're many ways to skin a cat, may i humbly present one here:
ReplyDeleteA Question for Liu Shijiu Bai Juyi
Green-foam'd new wine in bottle is gleaming;
Light and warmth the small, red-clay stove's beaming.
Snow, the night sky is about to cough up.
Come, m'friend, won't you drink with me one last cup?
Dear Frank,
ReplyDeleteI am afraid I have to say you have added far too many words, e.g. "bottle", "gleaming", "light", "warmth", "beaming", "last".
Best wishes, Andrew Wong.
hi, andrew,
ReplyDeletereading it again, you're so right!
and you're training me as a "minimalist translator". thanks!
should see some improvement in the following new version:
【问刘十九】 唐·白居易
绿蚁新醅酒, 红泥小火炉。
晚来天欲雪, 能饮一杯无?
A Question for Liu Shijiu Bai Juyi (Tang)
O Green-foamed new wine;
Small, red-clay stove fine.
Snow, the night sky is about to cough up!
Come, of wine won't you drink with me one cup?
hi, andrew,
ReplyDeletei think the latest version below is
closest to bai juyi's original:
A Question for Liu Shijiu Bai Juyi (Tang)
Invit'ng green-foamed newly-fermented wine
Is being warmed over small, red-clay stove fine.
Snow, the night sky is about to cough up!
Come, of wine won't you drink with me one cup?
Dear Frank, Sorry to be a wet blanket. Your "fine" in line 2 is a little artificial, and I don't quite like your "cough up" in line 3. Best wishes, Andrew Wong.
ReplyDeleteall your points agreed. may i have one last shot at this?
ReplyDeleteA Question for Liu Shijiu Bai Juyi (Tang)
Inviting green-foamed new-fermented wine,
Warmed o'er small, red-clay stove in pot confined.
Snow is going to fall tonight, you see --
Of this wine, won't you drink one cup with me?
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteI've translated this poem as well, thought i'd share:
ReplyDeleteGreen ant lees, fresh batch of grain,
Red bricks, hot little stove.
Come night there’ll be snow,
Stop by for a snort?
Nick Kaldis
I thank Nick Kaldis for his rendition of this beautiful little poem by Bai Juyi. While I have done it rhymed and metered, he has done it, like most translators since Arthur Waley, in free verse. I wonder if he would share with us his views on the choice of the form.
ReplyDeleteMight I try my hand at translating this simple quatrain?
ReplyDeleteDregs sink in the dark new wine
Brewing over the small red stove.
The evening snow is late to Heaven,
Care to try a cup?
Hey Jack V. and Andrew,
ReplyDeleteI love Jack's translation, except should it read "late from heaven"?
In my [1st] posted translation, I couldn't nail the end-rhyme, so i went with what i feel to be the tone. I actually responded to Andrew's request to comment on my choice, by emailing him a second version of this poem which hasn't been posted [my computer can't seem to post via the website], in which I've tried matching the original as closely as possible, with a near-perfect pentasyllabic version with a very close off-end-rhyme: "stove" & "no":
Green lees, fresh brewed shine,
Red bricks, glowing stove.
Come night there’ll be snow,
Share a swig or no?
Nick
You raise an interesting point, Nick. I'll keep that in mind.
ReplyDeleteI like your translation as well. My attempts at making a metered version were only semi successful, but I prefer free verse to be able to express what I think Bai Juyi really meant.
I'm also not a Chinese scholar, only a lowly college student who presented and explained this poem for his Chinese class oral report.
Hi, Andrew,
ReplyDeleteI was a student of Chinese language in my youth and am designing a personal site for myself and would like to include a couple of Chinese poem starting with 涼州詞 the first I memorized by heart and still know. My friend showed me 問劉十九 and I like its warmer friendlier feeling.
Would it be ok if I post your translation on my site and link back here to give you credit?
Sincerely,
Scott
Dear Scott,
ReplyDeleteLooks like there is a lot of interest in this poem, if not also my rendition, and I gladly and gratefully give you permission to post it on your site with a link to mine and credit to me acknowledged. Now that I am re-visiting this post, I think it appropriate to finalize my rendition as:-
Bai Juyi: At Home to Mr. Liu Shijiu
1 At home----an ebony, foamy new wine,
2 On a little stove of red clay, warming.
3 Care for a cup of the good stuff? I say,
4 Ah, snow in the evening sky is forming.
I have effected the amendments in my original post.
I had written separately to Scott Gruber saying I had to re-consider my line 1. This I have now done, and I have decided to slightly amend my line 1 by revising "foamy" to read "bubbly" (as I did on 3 December 2009 in comment #2 above), which is preferred for the "b" alliteration and the "y" assonance. I am taking this opportunity to re-arrange my rendition in such a way that after "At home", the rest of the poem reads like the text of Bai's invitation to Liu. Thus:
ReplyDelete1 At home: An ebony, bubbly new wine,
2 On a little stove of red clay, warming.
3 Care for a cup of the good stuff? I say,
4 Ah, snow in the evening sky is forming.
I have effected the amendments in the post. I have also made additions to my notes.
Not sure anyone is still following this conversation, but here is my attempt:
ReplyDeleteGreen lees of fresh-brewed beer
Small red clay stove aglow
The sky at dusk bodes snow
Come share a cup of cheer?
I thought beer is more likely to be foamy than wine, so I took the liberty of changing the type of alcohol
I like Allyson's rendition, but I'm not sure if "beer" captures what the liquor would have been like? Also, 'green ants' captures the poet's imagination of what the layer of surface lees look like, but "Green lees" is still very pleasant to the ear. Line 2 in Allyson's version is particularly fine...
ReplyDeleteNick
Thanks for sharing your version, Allyson! I appreciate the unique rhyme and rhythm. Since people are still posting on this, I thought I'd share my updated version (my original is shared above as "Jack V."). I ultimately decided to adopt English common meter for this one:
ReplyDeleteGreen foam atop the heady brew
A small stove of red clay
The evening sky will yield snow soon
You’ll drink a cup, or nay?
Here's my version
ReplyDeleteA new pot of dark mulled wine
brewing on the small red clay wood stove -
evening comes on, the sky about to snow -
won't you drink at least one cup with me?
So fascinating! Thanks to Andrew for being the "yeast" here :) I would also like to give it a try:
ReplyDelete1 Newly brewed wine with greenish dregs,
2 O’er a small stove, of red clay, warming. #
3 This evening it will snow it seems;
4 Would you come o’er for a drink?
(# words in this line are quite similar to Andrew's translation)
Decided to use "lees" instead of "dregs," as used by Nick and Allyson. Below is the revised translation, with some other slight changes:
ReplyDelete1 Newly brewed wine with greenish lees,
2 O’er a small stove of red clay, warming.
3 This evening it will snow, it seems;
4 Would you care come o’er for a drink?
Amazing to see a conversation that's been going on for ten years! Here are my contributions:
ReplyDelete(1) To Liu Yutong, 19th in his generation
New-brewed wine with a blooming green head,
A hot, squat stove with peat blooming red,
Snow is blooming in the evening sky,
So why not drink, you and I?
(2) To my friend Liu Yutong, 19th eldest in his generation of the Liu Clan
Hot coals are red,
New wine is green,
It's going to snow,
Come drink, Liu Nineteen!
Obviously version 1 is a little more serious! I quite like using cheeky modern forms to express the lighter side of Tang poetry, though. The first version may be a little pompous, though I'm hoping the last line deflates it sufficiently.
Chinaphil's #2 rhymed version is indeed cheeky and, despite liberties taken, still quite lovely. Using the addressee's name to complete a rhyme in the text of the poem is brilliant.
ReplyDeleteI may have to forgo IPAs tonight for some Tequila Blanco which is as close to green a liquor as i have...
Nick
Thank you for being a source of positivity and optimism – your blog reminds me to always see the silver lining! Join the Retro Bowl Unblocked community and lead your team to gridiron glory with your tactical prowess!
ReplyDelete